From Aviation Week May 17, 1999
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
NTSB Re-interviews Flight
800 Witnesses
James T. McKenna/Washington
Safety investigators are wrapping up their review of hundreds
of eyewitness
accounts of the July 17, 1996, crash of TWA Flight 800, several
officials
close to the investigation said, including the re-interviewing
of witnesses
who were in the best positions that night to see whether a missile
struck
the 747-100.
The wrap-up work by the Witness Group for that accident investigation
comes
as the key federal agencies continued arguing over the conduct
of the probe
into Flight 800's crash into the Atlantic off East Moriches,
N.Y. The crash
killed all 230 on board.
At a Senate hearing May 10, present and former government employees
testified that FBI officials seemed determined to conclude that
Flight 800
was downed by a bomb, that they hindered and mistreated officials
from other
agencies who argued that a problem on the aircraft was more likely,
and that
the FBI violated basic precepts of forensic science and criminal
science in
investigating the crash.
"The leadership of the FBI was a disaster," Sen. Charles Grassley
(R-Iowa),
who chaired the hearing, said.
The Witness Group's reexamination of the eyewitness accounts of
the crash is
one of the last major tasks yet to be completed in the safety
board's Flight
800 crash investigation. NTSB officials hope to conclude the
probe by
year-end, a step that most likely will be taken without identifying
a
specific cause for the explosion of the center fuel tank that
most officials
believe ripped the 747 apart in midair.
The Witness Group includes one representative each from the FAA,
Boeing, the
Air Line Pilots Assn., TWA and the International Assn. of Machinists,
which
represents the airline's mechanics. For the last year, the members
of that
group have been going over more than 2,500 documents containing
notes from
FBI interviews of people who claim to have seen the crash on
the evening of
July 17, 1996.
Their main goal, NTSB and other officials said, has been to sort
those
documents, categorize the information in them and assemble them
into a
verified database that can be searched easily for common threads
in
eyewitness accounts. But they have re-interviewed some eyewitnesses
who
appear to have been in the best position to have observed Flight
800's crash
sequence in real time and to provide a credible account of it.
The Witness Group, for instance, has re-interviewed a number of
pilots in
the air that night who might have seen Flight 800. On Mar. 26,
group members
traveled to Charlotte, N.C., to re-interview the captain of an
Eastwind
Airlines 737 that was passing over Long Island at the moment
the 747
exploded. The 737 was just above Flight 800's altitude of 13,800
ft. and
slightly behind the 747 at the time.
Group members also met with CIA officials Apr. 30 to get briefed
on that
agency's analysis, done for the FBI, that concluded that most
eyewitnesses
could not have seen the initial explosion of Flight 800, only
its immediate
aftermath. The most surprising information from the briefing,
several
individuals said, was the CIA officials' contention that they
told the FBI
as early as December 1996 that there appeared to be no evidence
that a
missile struck Flight 800.
Much of the group's work has been rudimentary. The FBI turned
over more than
2,500 individual documents, called FD-302s, for the bureau form
used to
record the notes of an eyewitness interview. The notes are not
direct
statements of each eyewitness' account but the interviewer's
version of that
account. The FBI fielded more than 1,000 agents to canvas the
New York area
for clues to what might have happened, but interviewers also
included local
law enforcement personnel who turned over notes to the FBI.
Some of the interviews in the days immediately following the crash,
however,
were done by FBI agents in league with analysts from the Defense
Intelligence Agency's Missile and Space Intelligence Center,
who were "among
the U.S. government's foremost experts on shoulder-launched surface-to-air
missiles," Lewis Schiliro testified at the hearing. He is the
assistant
director in charge of the FBI's New York office.
Safety board officials said the organization of the documents
was unclear.
Individual documents, for instance, do not identify whether they
record the
interview of a new witness or the follow-up questioning of one
previously
interviewed. The Witness Group has tried to sort the documents,
separating
accounts of witnesses who actually saw the 747 during the crash
sequence
from those who most likely saw just the aftermath on the surface
of the
Atlantic.
To a limited extent, officials close to the probe said, group
members have
attempted to verify the positions of the eyewitnesses on the
night of the
crash to assess whether they had a clear view of Flight 800.
|