Flight 800: Accident Or Terrorist
Attack? Part 1
Military Aviation Group Calls For Congressional
Investigation
By Joey Mac Lellan for
Suffolk Life Newspapers
December 14, 1998
A group of retired military personnel, experienced
in aviation accident investigations, is calling for congressional
hearings and possibly a special investigator to review the TWA
Flight 800 incident which killed 230 people when the plane
exploded over the Atlantic Ocean just south of Moriches on July
17, 1996. In the 109-page report, written by Commander William S.
Donaldson, US Navy (Retired), the group charges that the plane
was destroyed by two high explosive anti-aircraft warheads (one
fired from near the Moriches Inlet and the other from a ship
about 17 nautical miles off shore), and that the President and
Department of Justice impeded the investigation. This report has
been "intentionally narrowed to focus primarily on physical
evidence, witness testimony and actions of officials in the
Justice and Transportation departments that have had a direct
impact on the historical record of the TWA Flight 800
incident," wrote Donaldson, whose investigation was
conducted in cooperation with the Associated Retired Aviation
Professionals.
The report was funded, in part, by the Subcommittee on Aviation
under the authority of the U.S. House of Representative Committee
on Transportation & Infrastructure. "Like most
Americans," said Donaldson, "I was very concerned when
TWA Flight 800 mysteriously exploded ... just two days before the
start of the Atlanta Olympics." The retired Navy commander
said he followed the FL800 investigation in the media, initially,
because "it was so unusual for something like this to happen
to a Boeing 747 without an obvious external cause." Because
the National Transportation Safety Bureau (NTSB) plays a
"vital role in assuring the safety of the commercial airline
industry," Donaldson said he was "confident the NTSB
would quickly discover the cause." However, a year later, he
said he read a letter in the Wall Street Journal from NTSB
Chairman James Hall suggesting that "TWA FL800 exploded due
to some undiscovered mechanical failure, rather than some
external cause, such as a bomb or missile." The NTSB, with
assistance from the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), came up
with its mechanical malfunction theory, he noted, "despite
the known safety properties of modern Jet Fuel and the fact that
there were hundreds of eyewitnesses who saw something streaking
up from the surface which ended in the explosion of TWA
FL800." In the report, Donaldson wrote, "As a Naval
aviator and crash investigator, I was very familiar with
anti-aircraft missiles as well as the properties of Jet-A Fuel
and did not believe it possible that the fuel would explode
spontaneously.
" In fact, he added, "the fuel, which is very similar
to regular kerosene, will not easily light with a match, unless
the fuel is misted in the atmosphere or aerated by a fuel
injector." After consulting the Aviation Fuels Handbook and
conducting simple experiments with Jet-A Fuel, Donaldson said,
"I became convinced the Center Wing Tank did not explode
without some external cause." He said he contacted Hall with
his concerns, but was "immediately rebuffed." That
reaction, along with the fact that the NTSB refused to allow any
eyewitness testimony at an official FL800 hearing in Baltimore,
and that the only discussions at the hearing concerned the Center
Wing Tank (CWT) explosion theory, alarmed Donaldson. "They
appeared to only be interested in selling their story to the
media and the public." However, he added, "there are
thousands of aviation professionals who do not believe the
official version of the tragedy and there are hundreds of
eyewitnesses on Long Island who know what they saw and do not
appreciate the government telling them they were wrong."
Using statements from 47 eyewitnesses, the report offers what
more than 400 people (residents, scientists military personnel
and business executives) saw on that clear night over the
Atlantic Ocean. The report also lists 15 reported missile
sightings off the East End of Long Island between June 1987, and
September 1997 - including FL800 on July 17, 1996. "Based on
the fact that TWA FL800 was the likely target of a state [another
nation] sponsored terrorist attack , which is an Act of War, and
the fact that the Administration has covered up this act for
political expediency prior to the 1996 election, the Congress
should ... Hold Congressional Hearings into the cause of the
crash of TWA FL800 [and] Request the Justice Department appoint
an Independent Counsel to investigate." Suffolk County
Congressional members Michael Forbes, Rick Lazio and Gary
Ackerman said they have not read the report but will have their
respective staff review the information.